2025
| Name | Program |
| Aryn Taylor | Davenport University |
| Talen Verberg | Michigan State [Club] |
2024
| Name | Program |
| Tommy Clarey | Kalamazoo Valley Community College |
| Isaac Jurmu | Adrian College [Club] |
| Nick Slater | Hope College |
2023
| Name | Program |
| Canyen Veldhouse | Grand Rapids Community College |
| Mitch Smith | Palm Beach College |
| Aaron Hileman | Aquinas College |
2022
| Name | Program |
| Nic Bender | Hope College |
| Austin Deller | Aquinas College |
| Zach Elsbrie | Spring Arbor University |